Category: New cars

The Investigation Is Being Carried Out By ZR. Slippery Company Case

Video: The Investigation Is Being Carried Out By ZR. Slippery Company Case
Video: Дело раскрыто. Я знаю всех, кто пытался меня убить 2023, February
The Investigation Is Being Carried Out By ZR. Slippery Company Case
The Investigation Is Being Carried Out By ZR. Slippery Company Case


That morning, Elena Z., slowly, was driving to work. The next business negotiations promised to be difficult, and she turned her thoughts to the upcoming meeting. And the road required attention - frosty December, now and then sections of bare ice. Once again, hitting such a skating rink, the car suddenly skidded sharply. Lena frantically tried to level the car, but, probably, there was not enough experience: the passenger car, having lost control, crashed into a roadside ditch, turned over onto the roof.

Praising herself for the habit of buckling on, Elena tried to get out of the mangled car. Fortunately, an old Moskvich quickly drove up to the scene of the accident, from where two jumped out and helped get out of the snowy ditch. It was a pity to look at the car - the one-year-old Volkswagen Golf instantly became a pile of scrap metal. “Iron is nonsense,” the woman reassured herself, “everything is insured, the main thing is itself intact …”

Traffic police arrived quickly … less than three (!) Hours. The inspector immediately “went on the attack” - accused Elena of driving while intoxicated. The argument was convincing: “Well, can a sober driver just“fly out of the way”for no reason!” Even when the “pipe”, to the surprise of traffic police officers, recorded a complete absence of alcohol in the blood (later the same conclusion was confirmed test by a narcologist), they did not reconcile: “There is no accident without a culprit!” Well, if there is only one driver, you need to “hang the dogs” on him. As a result, a resolution appeared in which Helen was charged with violation of paragraphs 9.1 and 10.1 of the Rules and a decision was made under article 12.15 part 2 of the Administrative Code. Guilty and must pay a fine of 200 rubles!

Without expecting any trick, Elena came to an insurance company, where she was insured by AutoCASCO, hoping to get money quickly and without hassle. If she knew what she would have to face … She was already insured in the National Insurance League, infamous to our readers of the NSL (we have sued her more than once, see, for example, ZR, 2004, No. 1).

Unlike the day when Elena came here to pay a fee, they met her at the office more than coolly. We had to wait an hour in the reception room before being invited to the office of a company lawyer.

- So you yourself are to blame! - Immediately said an unrepresented young man. - In our rules it is written: if an insured event occurred as a result of a violation by the insured of the current legislation, the insurance indemnity is not paid. So I can’t help you with anything. All the best!

True, for some reason the young man refused to repeat the same thing in writing. Elena had no choice but to come to us. It was December 2002 …


I must say that such situations are not uncommon today. Strictly speaking, the refusal of the NSL to pay insurance indemnity formally could be considered legal. As we have already written more than once, the rules of voluntary insurance, unlike the rules of compulsory liability insurance, each company has its own. They are an integral part of the contract between the client and the company and are binding on both parties. And any violation of the rules by the client is the basis for the refusal to pay insurance compensation. But only formally. Everything is far from simple.

Insurance, of course, should not be a tool to protect offenders. The law (article 928 of the Civil Code) expressly prohibits the insurance of illegal interests. Otherwise, anyone could insure, for example, the risk of paying a fine for violating the Rules of the Road or the risk of incurring criminal penalties for committing a crime. It is not difficult to guess what this would lead to. That's just self-respecting companies (and customers) directly stipulate what exactly should be understood as “illegal interests”, otherwise the meaning of insurance will be completely lost. The words “Violation of the current legislation” are too general, and insurers dishonest, trying to hide behind them, try to refuse to pay the client. After all, any violation of the Rules is nothing but a violation of applicable law. Therefore, if you get into an accident and find himself the culprit, you can’t see the money with a cleverly drawn up contract. And it will be pointless to sue - the client’s signature is in the insurance policy: he is familiar with the rules of this company and has committed himself to strictly abide by them. The court will refuse the lawsuit.

But, you must admit: it’s one thing when the client is a malicious violator of the Rules and got into an accident as a result of a deliberate violation (for example, he drove into the oncoming lane to go around the traffic jam or got behind the wheel while intoxicated). In this case, he really should be fully responsible for the harm done to him, and the refusal of the insurance company will be completely fair. It’s completely different - when an accident occurs due to a simple accident, even if inattention, but not in any way the malicious intent of the client! It is for such cases that voluntary insurance exists. For the fact that the company assumes certain risks of the client, she receives money.

In our case, there was no intent on the part of Elena, although the fact remained that in accordance with the decision of the traffic police there was a violation of the Rules in the actions of Z. From a formal point of view, this did not mean at all that she was unequivocally to blame for the accident. The issue of guilt in an accident is decided only by the court. But if you sue the NSL, having this decision in hand, it will be quite difficult to prove Elena's innocence. Practice shows that in such cases, courts more often take the side of the traffic police. Based on this, we decided to appeal the decision. Fortunately, the ten-day period for appeal has not yet passed, and we wrote a complaint addressed to the head of the traffic police department.

The boss, fortunately for us, turned out to be not only a real professional, but also an extremely nice person. The whole conversation took no more than half an hour. He carefully listened to us, read the complaint and … apologized for the actions of his employee. Then he canceled the decision.

We waited 10 days - the time required for this decision to take effect - and together with Elena we went to the insurance company. Not really counting on success, they wrote a statement and attached a resolution of the traffic police to it. The same young man, without batting an eye, repeated his tirade word for word, after which, a little softer, added: “Well, if you want, we will pay you 4 thousand dollars …” Thank you, of course, for such unheard of generosity, but the amount, indicated in the insurance policy, which the insurance company is obliged to pay to Elena in case of theft or complete destruction of the car, is almost three and a half times more - 14 thousand (!) dollars. We had no choice but to go to court.


Popular by topic


Top 10 Video Of The Channel "Behind The Wheel" In Youtube -

In 2014, the video channel The article continued to replenish with the next interesting videos: test drives, reviews, presentations, reports

Read More
Motorization Of Russia: Catch Up And Overtake Libya

Despite the status of the once first market in terms of the number of cars sold in Europe, Russia's motorization leaves much to be desired. We are in 52nd place for Libya

Read More
Maintenance Renault Logan / Sandero For 90 Thousand Kilometers

How to carry out maintenance Renault Logan (Logan) / Sandero (Sandero) on 90 000 km of run independently. All work on the regulations, supplies, price

Read More
Editor'S Choice
  • New Format Numbers Coming Soon

    From January 1, 2019, the new GOST R 50577-2018 “State Registration Vehicle Signs. Types and main sizes. Technical requirements"

  • How To Wash Your Hands After Repair - Choose The Best Tool

    What means for cleaning heavily soiled hands are most effective and how to use them to wash your hands and not harm your skin? Article experts tested 18 hand cleansers and provide an answer. Reviews, prices

  • Big Studded Tire Test: Eight Rivals And Two Sensations

    Studded R16 tires for crossovers Nokian HKPL 9 SUV, Continental IceContact 2 SUV, Yokohama iceGUARD iG65, Gislaved Nord * Frost 200 SUV, Goodyear UltraGrip Ice Arctic, Nordman 7 SUV, Michelin X-Ice North 3, Nexen Winguard WinSpike WH62: comparative test snow, ice and asphalt, reviews, prices, expert assessment

  • Tricky Bolt Tool

    How to make a device for loosening a bolt or nut if the place along the axis of the fastener for a standard head with a screw is not enough. Useful advice, description, photo

  • Great Battery Test. Not All Survived

    An examination of the batteries, annually conducted by experts. An article on the bench equipment of NIIC AT 3 Central Research Institute of the Russian Ministry of Defense, this time passed under a new, more stringent program. The winners are the Russian Tyumen Battery Premium battery and the Korean American and Medalist

  • Seagull GAZ-13 And Its Overseas Prototypes

    Seagull GAZ-13 - a cult car of the 1950s - made according to American patterns. Find out how much she has in common with Packard Patrician, Chrysler, Cadillac and Ford models

Best reviews for the week
Popular for the day